Should I buy?

Thoughts, Ideas and General Questions
stevie135
Posts: 10
Joined: Sat May 01, 2021 4:05 pm

Should I buy?

Post by stevie135 »

Dear All

New to the forum - in fact new to boating! Well, I have a kayak but that's another story. I've seen a Shetland 535 Cuddy thats not been used in about 2 years, I recently approached the owner and hes said he will take £1500 for her. For this I would get -

The boat
Trailer (unbraked)
50hp 4 stroke Mercury outboard (1996)
Spare 4 HP outboard
Numerous bumbers etc,
safety gear (some of which is out of date)
3 brand new sea life jackets
2 new (ish) captains chairs boled to the spongy deck :-)

Seem to good to be true right? Well heres the thing, shes not in great condition. The hull seems fine but the cockpit deck is spongy to say the least. There seems to be firm cross members that I am assuming are fibeglass and part of the boat under the deck and these feel solid. Myself and the owner were both able to walk on the deck despite it sponginess.

Obviously there is a lot of work to do here, much of the marine ply that has been used for additions on the deck needs replacing etc. I'm OK with this. My main concern is twofold - firstly weight.... am I likely to be over the 750kg max for unbraked trailers here? and secondly the deck, I'm assuming I could rip it all out and just fit a piece of marine ply - is this correct?

I would love to hear from anyone who has any advice regarding these elements or indeed any other. I've coveted this boat from afar for a long time and it feels right, but I am prepared to walk away.

Many thanks for any help

Steve
dellquay13
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina

Re: Should I buy?

Post by dellquay13 »

Hi,

The deck isn't too much of a problem, ply sealed top and bottom in fibre glass resin will take a very busy weekend, or two if you're slow like me.

The outboards are the big issue here, have you seen them running? At 25yr old the main is getting on a bit. If they start 2nd or 3rd time in a tank of water, or flush muffs then it is a start. After 1/2 dozen tries on the big outboard and still not starting then there is work to be done, and usually not cheap. Better still try them on water where you can put a good few revs on, even if still on the trailer just backed in to the water, not necessarily afloat.

A 750kg trailer is borderline, you have to include the weight of the trailer in that too. The boat hull weighs about 375kg, google the specs for everything else, including the trailer if it doesn't have a plate.

The price today isn't bad, boats are at a covid staycation premium this year, and brokers can't get low end stock fast enough. But that all depends on the condition of the outboards, most of the value in old boats is the motor, the hull is the cheap bit.

Try to get someone who knows about outboards to have a look at it running...
If you buy it, get the engines serviced professionally, with new water pump impellors. After that you might want to take over the servicing yourself.

Finally, although boats are holes in the water that need regular filling with crisp new tenners to keep them at their best, I think they are the best way to waste crisp new tenners.
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
stevie135
Posts: 10
Joined: Sat May 01, 2021 4:05 pm

Re: Should I buy?

Post by stevie135 »

Thanks dellquay, apparently the motors - certainly the 50hp is well serviced and was running well. I’ll take your advice on a full service for both first should I proceed!

I think the weight is the main issue so going to workout that first - a new trailer would be a budget buster!
KenGreenaway
Posts: 11
Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2021 1:34 pm

Re: Should I buy?

Post by KenGreenaway »

I'm in the middle of restoring a Family Four which has involved replacing the cockpit floor. A bit of sponginess will, I suspect, mean rotten ply which will need replaced. A quick fix would be to lay new sheets over the existing floor but that won't get rid of the problem and will lead to more work in the future. The chances are that the foam under the floor will also be wet and there's no way for it to dry out. I removed the complete floor and dug out the foam. This revealed rotten cross members and a lot of dampness at the bottom of the boat. New cross members and 12mm marine ply sheets installed and I now have a solid floor that I know I can rely on. Remember to coat everything with epoxy resin. I am filling the area below the deck with sealed (empty!) plastic bottles and have installed a couple of 8" inspection hatches. A lot of work but actually quite enjoyable. Most boat owners like to have a project to get on with anyway. Check out the photos on my original post to see the work in progress.
If you find any extra cash try to get a 60hp motor if you want to get on the plane easier.
stevie135
Posts: 10
Joined: Sat May 01, 2021 4:05 pm

Re: Should I buy?

Post by stevie135 »

Hey great thanks! By the way - I bought!! Paid £1k in the end. Bargain I feel
dellquay13
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina

Re: Should I buy?

Post by dellquay13 »

It's a very good price for this year, if the motors just need an annual service, even considering the repair to the cockpit sole.
As for the 60hp mentioned by Ken, true for an F4, but they weigh nearly twice as much as a 535, the 50hp will be fine, especially if you have power trim on it.
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
Clive
Posts: 548
Joined: Sun Jun 23, 2019 8:41 am

Re: Should I buy?

Post by Clive »

Yes really good - trailers go for that much!
4+2 (1988) 35hp Honda outboard, currently in a field outside Horsham.