Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Thoughts, Ideas and General Questions
dconnx
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu May 18, 2023 8:27 am

Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by dconnx »

Hi all,

I've got an early Shetland family 4 (the type with a single piece curved windshield and the engine protruding into the cockpit). I currently have it in a sea harbour marina (maybe it's better as a river boat but I live by the sea).

The cabin drain hole, which I think should be a pipe going to the starboard side drain hole, is blocked. Actually more than blocked it's usually full of water and I can stick my finger in the hole and feel wet foam and no evidence of a pipe in there at all.

I've got an old 60HP Mariner 2 stroke engine on the back. I really don't go faster than 6 or 7 knots I think (just using a KPH app on my phone). Also the boat leans to the starboard side (mind you I've got 2 batteries in the rear starboard box/seat and a spare 6HP engine on that side so I'm planning on moving the batteries to the port box/seat and see if it helps). A person (say 70KG) standing on the port edge will balance it up.

This makes me a bit concerned that the foam down there might be waterlogged - I've had the boat out of water for the last couple of years
until last month but of course I'm sure it could have picked up a load of rain (there is a new canopy, from Shetland boats, over the cockpit but I'd say water could have been getting in everywhere all the same).

Are there any other Shetland Family 4 boat owners out there that know anything about this drain hole and the pipe or whatever and how it should
work (is it meant to be an actual pipe?) I'm thinking about taking an angle grinder to the floor in the cabin and making an access around the drain hole to get a better look.

I'm interested to hear from anyone with some knowledge of what is under the floor and the best way to check.

Thanks very much for any info,

Derek
dellquay13
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina

Re: Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by dellquay13 »

Can you post pictures of the drain holes? I don’t recognise the description of them, especially the starboard side drain hole. My F4 has none of these.
I have replaced both the cabin and cockpit soles in the past, and while there are small limber holes in the lowest part of the stringers to allow water to drain aft under the foam to the sump under the engine well, there are no other holes in the hull other than the stern tube and drain bung at the bottom of the transom.
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
dconnx
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu May 18, 2023 8:27 am

Re: Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by dconnx »

That's very interesting that you say you don't recognise any side drain hole. I wonder did a previous owner add the drain hole? There is a similar sized hole in the cabin too and I just assumed there was a pipe from that floor hole to the starboard side to drain away any cabin water. We only purchased the boat a couple of years ago (a Covid project for me and my sons). I think I'll open up the floor this weekend and have a look in there.

Photo here: https://compute.eolas.io/boat/boat-arrow-to-hole.png

Image
dellquay13
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina

Re: Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by dellquay13 »

That is the wash basin skin fitting on mine, about 3” above the cabin sole level if memory serves, my F4 has been laid up in a boatyard now for a couple of years.
The cabin sole would have a table pedestal base recessed in, the hole would be about 2 1/4” diameter if the fitting was removed.
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
dconnx
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu May 18, 2023 8:27 am

Re: Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by dconnx »

Hi @dellquay13 - Yes you are 100% right - it's the sink drain (it's back that far too) - I just didn't realise it. I have the pedestal base hole too but I've got an extra hole, perhaps 1" diameter, back from the pedestal hole which someone else must have made. This weekend I'm going to open up a bit of the floor and check the foam. On another forum (Facebook Shetland owners group) it's been suggested that I might have other issues like mismatched prop pitch on the Mariner 60 for the boat but I'm going to check the floor because I have a feeling that I've got a problem with water in the hull - only one way to find out.
dellquay13
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina

Re: Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by dellquay13 »

The prop pitch is easily checked if you have an accurate tachometer, and a wide open space of calm water with no speed limit.
With a lightly loaded boat and wide open throttle (WOT) you should be running at about 5000-5500 rpm, and probably about 20-22knots
On a healthy large outboard running properly, if your prop is pitched too high you will lose about 200rpm per extra inch of pitch, or gain 200rpm for every inch of pitch if you are under propped.
Eg if max rpm is about 4600rpm your prop is too tall by about 2-3”, if your max rpm is 6000 your prop is too short by 2-3”.
A good prop repairer can re pitch a prop, or buy another.

Here in the UK a good company is Steel Developments, but Brexit probably has made it easier to find someone inside the EU for you.

Leaky cabin windows are the usual culprit for water under the sole of an F4, along with the joint between the hull and the deck coming unglued under the rubbing strip. The original bolts will probably have rusted out under there too by the age of your boat, I replaced my hull bolts around 2006 I think, about the same time as the windows.
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
daveflack
Posts: 291
Joined: Fri Nov 08, 2013 6:54 pm
Location: Black Hawk "Atlast"Ullswater, now a 4+2

Re: Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by daveflack »

Hi, are the holes you're asking about the holes used by Shetland to inject the foam into the void spaces ? they would nomally have a plastic blanking plug but this could have gone missing. I'm not aware of "piped" drains other than sink or bilge pump outlets.
dconnx
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu May 18, 2023 8:27 am

Re: Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by dconnx »

Just an update: I should have called this thread "My boat leans to the side. I have a hole in the floor with water and wet foam in it. I don't seem to go very fast with my [old] 60HP engine"

First: The leaning to the side is because on the starboard side I have a backup 6HP engine and two batteries in the under-seat box (and one battery is a heavy Sonnenschein AGM marine battery). I moved the batteries to the port side box and the boat levelled up nicely (tomorrow I have to run 3 X 25mm2 wires between the boxes to get power working again).

Second: The holes/foam: It turns out I had 2 random 1" holes (one in the cabin and one in the rear port-side battery/storage box) - made by a previous owner I suppose. Both were full of water. So in both places I angle grinded out a square access holes to see what's up - and now I know that the floor is made of plywood with fibreglass on top. I didn't' see any stringers but my access holes are small or maybe there are no stringers and only foam (in which case it's pretty important for the hull structure). The state of the rear foam is the same as the cabin (very good I think really on balance). In the cabin I made a square access hole maybe 150mm X 150mm where my weird 1" hole was. The hole went a couple of inches into the foam alright. The plywood was a bit wet and slimy on the bottom but it was pretty tough as I had to prise it out. I dug the foam out down to the hull (7" from the floor to the hull BTW) - this was very easy to dig with a thin paint scraper type tool - and at the bottom was water seeping in as I removed the last bit of bottom foam - maybe 1" deep in the middle of the hole with was the middle of the V shaped hull and I mopped that up (I think slowly more is seeping in - I'll see tomorrow). The foam though was very dryish as I was slicing through it and breaking it up into bits - it wasn't water sodden like I've read other peoples comments on. So it looks like [if you've got holes in your floor] even it water does get down below the floor that doesn't mean that the foam will soak it all up. But I notice there are no channels or any obvious way for water to escape if it does get below deck. The only exit I think is the drain hole at the bottom of the stern of the boat - and I have the boat in water right now so I have a bung in that hole. Even then there doesn't seem to be any pre-designed gap/channel/drain to aim water towards the back to get out. It was interesting to get a feel for the distance between the floor and the hull in the two locations.

Third: I'll check out my speed again with my old 2 stroke Mariner 60 - it's all a bit rickety and old and anything could be mismatched or wrong so this will take more looking at now (as @deliquay13 detailed)

Now that I've gouged out two new big holes in my floor I'm just going to check for any more water and mop it up and get hold of a couple of suitable sealable doors and install them with epoxy maybe in both locations.

I took photos of the whole thing in case anyone is interested.

Derek
dconnx
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu May 18, 2023 8:27 am

Re: Family 4 (maybe waterlogged foam)

Post by dconnx »

daveflack wrote: Sat May 27, 2023 7:33 pm Hi, are the holes you're asking about the holes used by Shetland to inject the foam into the void spaces ? they would nomally have a plastic blanking plug but this could have gone missing. I'm not aware of "piped" drains other than sink or bilge pump outlets.
Hi Dave,

I think you are 100% right - the holes are too well made to be a hole cutter and the edges are bevelled down. This makes much more sense. So the caps/blanking-plugs just went missing over time (and then of course for sure rain got in)