Newbie to boats and forum

Thoughts, Ideas and General Questions
Paulsjenny
Posts: 92
Joined: Wed Dec 26, 2012 7:55 am
Location: Bristol

Newbie to boats and forum

Post by Paulsjenny »

Hi there , I'm new to the boating world and have been given a shetland 535 as a joint birthday /Christmas present :like:
It is a project but won't take long to get on the water (hopefully ), but will be after some advice on bits and pieces . I'm very much looking forward to bringing Jennifer ( the boat) back to life .
My very first question will have to be , what size engine is best for a shetland 535 which will be used for sea fishing , it doesn't have a engine so feel this will be a good start :-D

I look forward to any replies.

Merry Christmas and happy new year .
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 862
Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2011 3:00 pm
Location: "Phonix" , Tuckton Basin, Christchurch

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by admin »

Hello and Welcome. Our resident engine guru is dave in Scotland - username daveinglasgow. I will get him you give you some advice

Sue - ADMIN
There is NOTHING--absolutely nothing--half so much worth doing as simply messing about in boats.
Kenneth Grahame
User avatar
Coddy
Posts: 96
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2011 3:51 pm
Location: Dorset

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by Coddy »

Hi

I have a 535 which I use for sea fishing, I have a 40hp 2-stroke which will push her along flat out at about 18-20Kts however I would suggest a 50hp engine would give you a good start.
The boat is capable of a maximum output of 65hp but that was back when 2-stroke engines were the engine to have, 4-strokes can be heavier than a 65hp 2-stoke so be careful when you start looking for an engine and check the weights.

If looking at a new or newish engine check out the Evenrude ETEC engines or Tohatsu engine range as both are give good outputs and are a bit lighter in weight. If you want a 4-stroke then nearly all the major manufactures are very similar to each other, some give multi year warranties, which you pay in the buying price. Also check out your local marine engineer and see which make they specialise in, having to trail your boat to a main dealer, if far away, can be a pain!
Don't go over the max output rating of the boat or you might have insurance problems!

Good luck

Dave
:like:
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by daveinglasgow »

Hi

Ok thy]e first thing that I must get across is that you need 2 engines for the sea as follows:

1 x main engine to get you to your required speed and will depend on lots of things listed below
1 x auxiliary engine to get you back to the nearest safe place i.e. dream engine Honda 2.3 long shaft new at around £600 with 6 years warranty or 2nd hand from ebay 6-10 years old at around £400. Dont go less HP than this and no more than 3.5 as the weight will be a pain in the you know where. Oh tohatsu is the same engine as the mercury and mariner up to 30hp and have the same warranty as all are made by Nissan and just have different stickers

Main engine key questions

how often will you use it and for how many hours ( best guess needed)
what top speed do you want (in mph is fine)
budget

if you can answer the above I can give you a lot better advice or call me on 0759 563 8185 any time/ day before 9pm

oh and last but not least the best makes are yam and honda and would not use an etec even if it was free due to how many problems they get per number sold. They also have the shortest (by a long way) max number of hours for warranty claims and have even closed the UK office!

Dave
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
User avatar
Coddy
Posts: 96
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2011 3:51 pm
Location: Dorset

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by Coddy »

oh and last but not least the best makes are yam and honda and would not use an etec even if it was free due to how many problems they get per number sold. They also have the shortest (by a long way) max number of hours for warranty claims and have even closed the UK office!
I think the above statement is unfair and without facts and figures to back the claim about ETEC engines I would be wary of personal comments even if someone works for a marine engineering business but does not have the approved servicing rights for that particular engine. Regarding the warranty try looking on their warranty web page http://www.evinrude.com/content/pdf/en- ... itions.pdf which is for a 3yr standard warranty or 750hrs, this can be extended if you follow certain conditions as detailed on the site. I have a number of friends who use these engines and have not had any problems, however they do take them to be serviced at an authorised dealer who knows what is required on these engines as they are a bit specialised in how they must be maintained. Like most moden engine manufactures, all the dealers need specialised equipment and diagnostic systems to get the best out of the engine, this applies to cars as well as the marine industry.

I would also question Dave's statement that a 3.5hp auxiliary engine is sufficient to get you out of trouble, in some places I am sure this may be true but if you intend to use your boat in the Bristol channel or similar area with strong tidal flows then you will find you will be going backwards at full throttle when the tide is in full flow.

The best advice I would suggest is to get a "professional" advice from people who know the waters you intend to use your boat in, they are the RNLI and are very happy to give FREE advice before you spend any money. It does not matter where you live inland or near the sea, they have a team of experts who will give you all the advice and knowledge they have at their disposal to make sure you are as safe and prepared as you can be when going to sea. It is called Sea Safety Check and can be checked out here http://rnli.org/safetyandeducation/stay ... board.aspx

I am not sure where you live or intend to use your boat from but I would suggest you join your local sea fishing club, you will gain loads of advice and it is always good to know that there could be friends close by when you need them.

Just to put the record straight, I do not work for any marine or engine manufacturing industry but have gain my opinions from boat owning and fishing with friends for over 20 years.

Regards

Dave
:cool:
Paulsjenny
Posts: 92
Joined: Wed Dec 26, 2012 7:55 am
Location: Bristol

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by Paulsjenny »

Hi
Thankyou for your comments , sertenly something's to think about , for starters the weight of the engine is one thing i didnt think about but as I'm new to this I'm sure it's things like this that I will learn as I go !

I intend to use to boat at sea but not to far out , maybe a mile max to start with but will want a engine that can get me back safely , I'm unsure of my budget as of yet but will have more options once I know , this boat is a project that will need lots of things to be bought so I will have time to research all engines on the market and figure out which engine suits my boat best , as I said , I am new to this so any comments are appreciated .

Paul
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by daveinglasgow »

Hi

Just to confirm that I stand by my comments.

FACT: Evinrude closed their UK office due to v v bad sales figures:
FACT: Evinrude have the lowest percentage of commercial engines (Yam first and Honda 2nd with Honda's market share growing)
FACT: they have the shortest warranty of any engine
FACT: Per engines sold we have by far the highest number of problems with these and happy to prove it.
FACT: I have advised to stay clear of one engine range i.e. not even the whole evinrude range when the original poster could buy Yam, Honda, Mercury, Mariner, Tohatsu, suzi, other evinrudes, Johnson etc.

It is also a 2 stroke so it uses separate oil that is mixed with the fuel (done by an auto mixer which if it stops you will need an engine rebuild which is why on older 2 strokes fishermen turn this feature off) it is louder, uses more fuel (in fairness this applies to all 2 strokes) but it will accelerate slightly quicker (around 10%) and is a bit lighter so when they work they are great for water sports. Oh but they are naff at trawling so not good for many types of fishing which is what the original poster wanted to do.

Note: the 750 hour warranty that Dave brought up is true and shocking compared to Yam, suzi or honda as we see the commercial guys put 3-5 thousand hours on them on a regular basis and many run for 10 hours + per day. Oh and just to go even further on this Honda even offer a 2 year commercial warranty with no hours limits!!!!!

Last but not least it looks like Evinrude will stop making 2 stroke engines and move over to to more efficient and reliable 4 strokes (just like we have in all the cars we drive) so its a mute point as I dont think you will be able to buy a new one soon anyway. It also looks like Nissan will be making their small engines just like mercury and mariner as they are looking to reduce costs due to poor sales and yet there are no known problems with the current range.

Oh Dave and just to clear this up we only have approved rights for 2 of the above so if saying stay away from less than 10% percent of engines ranges (not makes) me bias when I can also prove my facts then I am delighted to be so as it will help keep people safe and help stop people throwing money away which has been v common on this forum as many are first time boat owners.

When did the original poster state he was in the bristol channel? he also did not state that he wanted to take it to Norway every Thursday either so unless he is going to be in less than 5 % of water in the UK the 3.5 will be fine and in over 90% of time the 2.3 will do the job and give him lots of other benefits. You will also notice that I gave my number as well so that we could talk about this further if required.

Your point re the RNLI is also misleading as they will provide free safety checks and as long as one of your engines is big enough to get you to safety they will take no interest in them. The furtherest I have seen any go is show someone how to start it and a quick check list of what to do if it does go wrong. They will give great advice how to be safe including life jacket tests, flairs , comms, but they will not even do a compression test so your main engine could not push a pea but they would deem it ok. Oh and they will also check your engine is secure but they will not act as a mechanic.
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by daveinglasgow »

Paul

weight will not be a problem for your main engine but will be a pain for your auxiliary as putting them on and off all the time becomes harder the heavier it is. My speed question is what you really need to think about i.e. pottering up to around 10 mph max speed or do you want to go 20mph-30mph?

Dave
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
Paulsjenny
Posts: 92
Joined: Wed Dec 26, 2012 7:55 am
Location: Bristol

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by Paulsjenny »

Dave

A bit of both to be honest , yes I want to potter along but also want to have a Bit of fun with it without being to stupid , I don't want something that will launch the boat out of the water when I open it up , I'm just looking for a good reliable safe engine that will get me out of trouble if needed .

As for the auxiliary engine , isnt this a small engine that sits on the side in case of emergency ? Would I need to remove every time and if so would I need to remove the main engine every time also ?

Paul.
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: Newbie to boats and forum

Post by daveinglasgow »

Hi

small engine first.

the aux is there to get you to "safe water" be that a bay, harbour, pier, or even simply calm water. It is not there to get you home or back to where you started hence it it is deemed big enough if pushes you along at slow walking speed. This is all good news as it means less money.

Now the bad news:

4 stroke outboards are not light with the lightest in the world (long shaft) being 13.5kg which is the single handed 2.3hp 4 stroke also known as the fisherman's friend. the next step up is around 18kg ( ignore the suzi 2.3 as it is water cooled and the pipes are just to small in that engine) and this means you either

1: need some way of stopping it being stolen
2: need to take it off each time and either lock in the cabin or even better take it home.

If you go down the 2 stroke route you are looking at a much older engine and whats really annoying is you will need to clean the carbs far more often as the oil and petrol will separate and block them. I also would beg the question if you would risk your life on a 10 year old + 2 stroke engine when you can get a good 4 stroke for a hundred to 2 hundred more but that is a budget and personal choice and as long as it works well you will be safe.

for me ( this is a personal thing) I would go with a 4 stroke and take it off as this engine is like my lifejacket i.e. vital

main engine

ok the 535 gets up at around 15-16 mph depending on load and conditions. As you want your engine to be running at no more than 80% revs (even a 4 stroke will drink a lot more above this number) your options are really up to 25hp and top speed 12-14mph or 50-60hp and a top speed of 26-32mph depending on sensible load, conditions etc.

there are lots of these around so next question would be budget and if you can buy before the first sunny day in feb as thats when everyone starts thinking about boats again and 2nd had prices rocket.

If you are going to keep you boat for 5+ years new is worth looking at as prices are rising each year and the hold the value v well. If you are thinking of selling in 1-2 years I would go second hand.

feel fee to call to discuss and I can quickly toalk you throuigh what to look for and avoid

Dave
0759 563 8185
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices