Fuel efficiency ...

Thoughts, Ideas and General Questions
rbmatthews
Posts: 106
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:02 am
Location: Northeast Scotland

Fuel efficiency ...

Post by rbmatthews »

Hi everyone

I know that we had this discussion once before on the old site (http://www.shetland.owners.org.uk/forum ... &forumid=1), but technology and membership has moved on from then, so I thought that it might be interesting to revisit it.

We recently upgraded our 1988 Mariner 75 clamshell to a 2012 Mariner 75 hp Optimax, both two-stroke, but the Optimax is Direct Fuel Injection (DFI). We were astounded at the improvement in fuel efficiency on a recent excursion on the west coast of Scotland. Overall we did 202.9 NM and used 106.3 litres of petrol (we measured these figures very accurately), which is an average of 1.91 NM/litre. Prop size is 17p. This was an average over a wide range of conditions - tootling along at displacement speeds (around 5 knots for our boat) right up to WOT (about 25 knots), going with the tide at 8 knots sometimes, against it at 8 knots other times, and smooth sea states through to moderate. In comparison, our old engine averaged 1.1 NM/litre over probably similar conditions in most cases, which is an increase in average fuel efficiency of 75% for the same engine 25 years later.

We also have a SmartCraft system which gives you instantaneous fuel consumption figures, and from these we calculated that we were often getting around 3 NM/litre for below hull speeds, but planing at 25 knots this dropped to about 1.2 NM/litre. Quite often we were pottering along at 4.5 knots with no current to speak of and getting about 1.5 litres/hour. I don't know what the old engine did at this speed as we couldn't measure its instantaneous fuel consumption, but I don't think it would be anywhere near this.

In addition to this, we used only 1.64 litres of DFI oil, which works out at a 65:1 petrol/oil ratio (the engine works this all out itself), so also savings over the 50:1 ratio that the old engine used. Mind you, at the cost of DFI oil, I would want to see some savings on this in any case!

In the old thread, it was thought that the most efficient speed was probably just on the plane, but only enough throttle to keep it there, which is at about 15 knots in our boat. In fact, we found that the most efficient was at displacement speeds (i.e. 3 NM/litre) and that this dropped to about 1.5 NM/litre at 15 kt.

I would be interested in what figures other members are getting with their combinations, and particularly to see if the four-strokes are really that much more efficient than a DFI two-stroke, for a similar sized engine and under similar conditions?

R.
Swannanoa, 1989 Shetland Family Four
http://shetlandf4.wordpress.com
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 862
Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2011 3:00 pm
Location: "Phonix" , Tuckton Basin, Christchurch

Re: Fuel efficiency ...

Post by admin »

Over to you Dave..............
There is NOTHING--absolutely nothing--half so much worth doing as simply messing about in boats.
Kenneth Grahame
User avatar
davidemania
Posts: 95
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 6:15 pm
Location: Monfalcone, eastern north Italy

Re: Fuel efficiency ...

Post by davidemania »

Very interesting matter, I'd definitely like to see how the discussion goes on!
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: Fuel efficiency ...

Post by daveinglasgow »

Hi

This is a huge area for debate and before I start the 2 vs 4 stroke on fuel, servicing etc there is no right or wrong , and every engine has its place its just a matter of what you want the engine to do but bellow I hope will dispel a few common myths and give a rough idea to the answers to your question.

old 2 strokes

v light
cheap to buy
all have carbs
heavy on fuel
best for acceleration i.e. they like to be on or off
not great at low speeds i.e. fishing , canals/ rivers etc

New 2 strokes

far better on fuel than any old style 2 stroke
on large engines they lighter than 4 strokes
smaller engines i.e. 40-60 are often heavier than 4 strokes but to be fair this is not a big big market i.e. a 40 etec comes in a 109-113kg compared to a honda at 96
reviews show they drink anywhere between 10-25% more fuel than 4 strokes
never seen a single engine with over 1000 hours let alone 5,000+ on it.

4 strokes

large engines are heavier
v quiet
best fuel economy
often seen with 5000-8000 hours (yams and Honda's) and mega reliable
Great for fishing , fuel economy, reliability
Bad for where max HP on the boat is required
bad for Buying i.e. expensive new and hold the prices v v well 2nd hand


Key points

when thinking of buying any engine think about:

1: what speed you would the boat to be able to do and cruise at
2: reliability ( remember that a good auxiliary with an older engine is better than 1 x new engine as even a new engine can have problems with bad fuel or if you hit something and damage the prop/ gear box)
3: what you will be using the boat for i.e. water skiing ( best with 2 stroke or if you must go 4 stroke one that has boosted low end torq) fishing (4 stroke)
4: How often you will use the engine i.e. if you are only doing 20-30 hours fuel economy is not as much as an issue compared to someone doing 100 hours so a cheaper 2 stroke could well be the better option.


Common Myths

auto mixing on old 2 strokes is a good thing. Sorry this is not true and you are better to mix fuel in the tank due to any failure of the auto mixer could ruin your engine so why risk it.
2 strokes are always lighter. This depends on size and in some cases the 4 strokes are lighter.
a good 4 stroke means you dont need a back up engine: This is often said and very dangerous as there are a few things that can stop even the best running engine i.e. hitting something and damage to the prop/ gear box, bad fuel, leaks in priming bulbs, flat batteries etc.
Both types of engines give same amount of power. This again is not true. if you take a 50HP 2 stroke and compare it with a brand new 4 stroke the 4 stroke will do better due to
a: engines lose power with age just like cars
b: engine ratings are now at the prop where as before they were at the power head

Summery

all engines have their place and it comes down to budget, use, boat, and in some cases personal preference and what is also available. so if you are not sure please ask.

Dave
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
User avatar
stanfolds
Posts: 75
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 12:40 pm
Location: Livvi, Shetland 570, Horning Norfolk.

Re: Fuel efficiency ...

Post by stanfolds »

Well said Dave, a very good reply, perhaps Admin could keep it as a sticky somewhere.

As an after thought, if you are worried about fuel efficiency and who isn't these days, make sure the hull below waterline is kept clean and the weight is as low as you can manage. I know my boat hasn't been lifted for a year now amd there are lots of tools, spares, lengths of rope etc that might come in handy but never seem to get used on board.

Stan