Pitch for Shetland 640
-
sag140
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2013 8:27 am
Pitch for Shetland 640
I recently put a mercury 40hp (1991) 2 cylinder 2 stroke on my Shetland 640 cruiser. The propeller is wrong as it is eating up way too much juice and steering feels heavy. I am unsure of the pitch of the prop but am certain it is wrong. It was suggested that to get anywhere near the plain if that is possible with 40hp or near to it a 13 pitch prop would be best. I use the boat for river use and a little coastal use. I know you should do tests to see the rate of petrol use revs etc but if I can get an idea of the best prop size at least the performance can improve for the remainder of the season and then I can come back with a little more idea next year. Thanks for any advice.
-
davidemania
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 6:15 pm
- Location: Monfalcone, eastern north Italy
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
well, going close to plane would be the worst way you'd like to bring your boat on the water, if your motor can't bring her over the bow wave it's very likely it will drink a lot for nothing. What pitch are you using now? If longer than 13 inches it is definitely too long. It would be important to know the maximum revs you could push your motor vs the maximum revs reported in the user manual.
Then I'd say that your boat would do best with more than 40 HP, it seems too little for her but it's only my opinion. Changing the propeller can help but won't do miracles.
ciao
Davide
Then I'd say that your boat would do best with more than 40 HP, it seems too little for her but it's only my opinion. Changing the propeller can help but won't do miracles.
ciao
Davide
-
sag140
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2013 8:27 am
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
Thanks for that answer . I get 4500 revs if that makes sense. So what pitch should I use. Also it is a very shallow V shape hull. I managed to get 7 to 8 knots form a Evinrude 9.9 4 stroke. I think 13 pitch should improve things a little but would like a little more advice.Nice to be a member.
-
sag140
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2013 8:27 am
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
Max revs for this engine are 5000 to 5500 if that helps further.
-
davidemania
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 6:15 pm
- Location: Monfalcone, eastern north Italy
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
My bet is your prop pitch is much too long, but it would be nice to listen to the experience of someone having the same boat as yours, and see how much power they are using.
It is hard to tell if a 13 inches would do without at least knowing what are you using now. I'd say you should go below 13, but again I am not an expert in the field.
ciao
Davide
It is hard to tell if a 13 inches would do without at least knowing what are you using now. I'd say you should go below 13, but again I am not an expert in the field.
ciao
Davide
-
dellquay13
- Posts: 556
- Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
- Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
Hi,
looking at the specs for this boat, at 6.40m long, 945kg hull weight and a max engine size of 45hp, I would guess it was never meant to get anywhere near planing speed, and to get it there you would want 80-100hp. 40hp is about the minimum for a 535.
Chris
looking at the specs for this boat, at 6.40m long, 945kg hull weight and a max engine size of 45hp, I would guess it was never meant to get anywhere near planing speed, and to get it there you would want 80-100hp. 40hp is about the minimum for a 535.
Chris
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
-
davidemania
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 6:15 pm
- Location: Monfalcone, eastern north Italy
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
Needless to say that pushing a boat that was never meant nor designed to plane with twice the maximum rated power could be quite dangerous!
-
sag140
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2013 8:27 am
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
Thanks for all the advice and help very much appreciated. Manufacturers recommend max engine size of 40hp although this has been revised to 50hp at a later date. I really do not go near coastal waters just tootle up the Tyne and have a good reserve engine which considering is only 4hp is very powerful and will move the boat quite nicely even upstream. My prop after some measurements appears to be 16 I will replace it to a 13 or 12. It seems from the Shetland site that this will improve the performance and also fuel use but will not do miracles. As commented the boat was never designed to hit the plane although that was said about my previous boat which did but then the boating world is always full of surprises usually costly ones!!!!. I think 8 to 10 knots is quite enough it may out perform that at full throttle but three quarter is generally as far as I do. As the speed limit is 5 knots and accounting for head winds etc and the fact I only take her out on calm days during the season I think that is enough. If I wished speed I have a speedboat a little old which is of course much lighter and will go like the wind. However in boating world speed is not important but being safe is. What does worry me is when I do go out the amount of people who have no qualification or experience and really are a nuisance as well as dangerous. I hold level 2 and 3 quals with radio certificate. I am not talking about those who have owned a boat for years and learned on the job, but some of the younger. I think like driving there should be a minimum level of qualification to pilot boats. It does horrify me that anyone can buy a boat and drive it and if they cannot read tide times or have little equipment on board it is no wonder accidents are on the increase.
-
davidemania
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 6:15 pm
- Location: Monfalcone, eastern north Italy
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
Well, thank you for your wise words. Here in Italy everyone can ride a boat up to 40HP (that's more than enough to kill yourself or others, by the way) then you need a license. In Neighboring Slovenia you need a license whatever the power, and that seems reasonable. Anyway, no matter what the prejudices about italians could be, usually people behave well while on the sea, trying not to hurt the others. Of course there is the occasional idiot now and then but it is rare and usually gets blamed hard.
Back to your case, a 16 inches prop with your motor and boat seems huge, going shorter should give you easier maneuvering and more acceleration... I'm finding a 13 inches too long for my boat that's quite smaller and with 10 HP more than yours. Le us know what your results will be.
ciao
Davide
Back to your case, a 16 inches prop with your motor and boat seems huge, going shorter should give you easier maneuvering and more acceleration... I'm finding a 13 inches too long for my boat that's quite smaller and with 10 HP more than yours. Le us know what your results will be.
ciao
Davide
-
sag140
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2013 8:27 am
Re: Pitch for Shetland 640
Will do David and thanks for the advice. In the UK any engine sizes go 60 100 200 etc. You do not need any licence to drive them. To me an accident waiting to happen. I have seen people go out with huge engines with no back up, no extra fuel on board or life jackets radios the usual essential equipment. Drive up the river straight into coastal waters which of course is a accident waiting to happen and really it has taken me 3 seasons to get near coastal water which is a totally different experience .In the UK we have quite a lot of canals which I am far more used to and it took me a while to deal with tides etc. Wish I had taken the course on engine maintenance then I would not be flapping on prop pitch. But then again my mate spends a lot of money on petrol to go a very short distance. I think his prop is really trying to tell him something but not a person who listens. Anyway tide at 4.30 I shall struggle on but soon prop will be changed and see what happens.