Family Four buying advice please

Thoughts, Ideas and General Questions
MikeUK
Posts: 8
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2013 6:01 pm

Family Four buying advice please

Post by MikeUK »

Hi,

I am looking to buy a Shetland Family Four and should be grateful for some advice.

My main concern is whether to stick with the Honda BF10 with which the boat is being offered or upgrade to a bigger engine.

My intention is to use the boat initially for canal and river cruising but in the longer term am likely to want to do some coastal hops.

I understand that one would need at least a 60 hp engine to get a family four planing with two passengers. This would be highly desirable for sea use but would seem to be complete overkill for my initial requirements.

My current thinking is that I would probably do best to buy the smallest engine that would get the boat up to maximum displacement hull speed (which I assume would be about 6kts) and upgrade to a larger engine at a later date.

Can anyone please tell me what horsepower I would need to achieve maximum displacement speed?

I am also wondering if it would be better for fuel efficiency to run a smaller engine at higher speed or a larger engine at lower revs?

I was also thinking that it might be desirable to go for an engine with electric start and power trim, although I would only use the latter to facilitate shallow water launching and clearing weed/debris from the prop. Does this seem like a sensible idea?

I was also considering fitting some form of prop guard to reduce the risk of fouling on inland waterways and possibly assist with low speed manoeuvring. Would this be advisable?

Any other thoughts on the matter (and anything else that I would be advised to consider!) would be greatly appreciated.

Regards

Mike
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 862
Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2011 3:00 pm
Location: "Phonix" , Tuckton Basin, Christchurch

Re: Family Four buying advice please

Post by admin »

I will get Dave our engine expert to drop you a line

Sue
There is NOTHING--absolutely nothing--half so much worth doing as simply messing about in boats.
Kenneth Grahame
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: Family Four buying advice please

Post by daveinglasgow »

MikeUK wrote:Hi,

I am looking to buy a Shetland Family Four and should be grateful for some advice.

My main concern is whether to stick with the Honda BF10 with which the boat is being offered or upgrade to a bigger engine.

My intention is to use the boat initially for canal and river cruising but in the longer term am likely to want to do some coastal hops.

Stick wit the BF10. great engine and more than enough power for rivers and canals

I understand that one would need at least a 60 hp engine to get a family four planing with two passengers. This would be highly desirable for sea use but would seem to be complete overkill for my initial requirements.

very much so and at weight that you dont need

My current thinking is that I would probably do best to buy the smallest engine that would get the boat up to maximum displacement hull speed (which I assume would be about 6kts) and upgrade to a larger engine at a later date.

60hp 4 strokes are like hense teeth so start looking now as good ones are rare. buy new if vat registered as that way you can run it for a few years and not lose money

Can anyone please tell me what horsepower I would need to achieve maximum displacement speed?

keep the 10hp oh and 4mph is the max speed on most canals.

I am also wondering if it would be better for fuel efficiency to run a smaller engine at higher speed or a larger engine at lower revs?

with the hours you will use and both being 4 strokes the difference will be pennies as the honda 10hp will not be reving at over 4800

I was also thinking that it might be desirable to go for an engine with electric start and power trim, although I would only use the latter to facilitate shallow water launching and clearing weed/debris from the prop. Does this seem like a sensible idea?

A 10hp is v v v v v easy to lift out of the water so no. re electric, I am guessing you have pull start?. if so you have been a wee bit unlucky as most are sold with both and sadly for what you would gain it will cost far more than its worth.

I was also considering fitting some form of prop guard to reduce the risk of fouling on inland waterways and possibly assist with low speed manoeuvring. Would this be advisable?

Great question and amazed it is not asked more often. the quick answer is no unless there are a lot of people in the water i.e. swimmers. sadley these things make steering worse and create a huge amount of drag/ effect cavitation. Government bodies are often forced to use them along with safety boats etc but you are lucky and dont need one
Any other thoughts on the matter (and anything else that I would be advised to consider!) would be greatly appreciated.

if you want to chat more about all things engine and your new boat please also feel free to call me any day but please before 9 pm ( sundays included)

Dave
0759 563 8185


Regards

Mike
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
MikeUK
Posts: 8
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2013 6:01 pm

Re: Family Four buying advice please

Post by MikeUK »

Hi Sue and Dave,

Thank you for your immediate and extremely helpful replies. Thanks too to Dave for your kind offer to have a chat. I think that you've answered all my questions, at the moment, but I may take you up later in the week if that is ok.

I didn't realise that the BF10 could have electric start, so will certainly check on what is fitted.

It certainly sounds as though the BF10 would be my best option in the first instance. I hope that I can get to try the combination before I have to make my final decision.

Will keep you posted as to how I get on.

Kind regards

Mike