fuel consuption

Thoughts, Ideas and General Questions
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

fuel consuption

Post by daveinglasgow »

Just thought I would post a quick comment about last weeks boating

1 x shetland 535 fully laden 50hp 4 stroke ( new demo engine)
1 x shetland family 4 mariner 70 hp 2 stroke

Miles covered 45 both boats
the 50hp used 12.5 l
the 70hp a shocking 70 L

Top speed for 50 hp just over 30 mph
Top speed 70hp 2 stroke 25 mph

Both engines were fully open for around 4-5 miles and the rest was at 5-8 mph

Dave
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
User avatar
stanfolds
Posts: 75
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 12:40 pm
Location: Livvi, Shetland 570, Horning Norfolk.

Re: fuel consuption

Post by stanfolds »

That's very interesting Dave but I suspect that it has as much to do with boat shape and size as the different engines.

I am about to do a prop change on my engine and have been thinking of doing a consumption check before and after. I am in a different league, 570 with an 8 hp 4 stroke on the broads with max speed limits of 6MPH, the engine is over proped for a heavy boat and feels laboured at high throttle openings, WOT is at least 1000 revs down. The method I am thinking of useing is to run the engine dry and fit a plastic bottle with 250 mils of fuel connected to a short length of pipe and fuel connector, reset the trip log and run at 6MPH until the engine stops and note the distance. I will repeat the experiment after the prop change and see if there is a difference. Lots of room for errors, the log only reads to point 1 of a mile ( tide should be OK as the log reads through the water), wind/weather etc. I might as well try a 4MPH run as well while I have the set up fitted. Even if there is little or no difference at least I will get a good idea of the consumption.

I will post the results of consuption, prop sizes and WOT when I have the results.

Stan
rbmatthews
Posts: 106
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:02 am
Location: Northeast Scotland

Re: fuel consuption

Post by rbmatthews »

Dave

Are you really comparing like-for-like here? Mariner 70hp engines were produced up to around 1989, I think - if so, you are really comparing an old 2-stroke engine with a modern 4-stroke. Of course we all know that old 2-strokes were gas-guzzlers, so it is hardly a fair comparison.

However, the technology has moved on with direct fuel injection and air compressors and the like. A more useful comparison would be a modern 2-stroke with a modern 4-stroke. Last year I did a comparison of fuel consumption figures of the Honda 75 and the Mariner 75 Optimax published by the manufacturers - see the analysis at http://shetlandf4.wordpress.com/2013/10 ... -4-stroke/ if you are interested. Basically, it showed that there isn't much difference in consumption between a modern 2- and 4-stroke - if anything, the 2-stroke had lower fuel consumption at higher rpm than the 4-stroke.

I can vouch for the Optimax 75 figures - I have recorded consumption at various rpm and it fits pretty much on the line given by Mariner (I will publish these when I get time). I have measured consumption accurately over a 200 mile trip fully laden in our F4, and we routinely average 2 NM/litre over a range of conditions which include trolling along to WOT - instantaneous figures are more than 3 NM/litre at lower rpm, which is approaching the figure of 3.6 miles/litre you give for the 50 hp (BTW was this nautical miles or ordinary miles?).

Stan - it will be interesting to see the sort of figures that you come up with. Another way would be to weigh the fuel tank before and after running it for a period of time at constant speed - I have used digital bathroom scales to do this (0.1 kg increments = 100 ml fuel approx), and it seems to work fine. You could also use a GPS to measure distance travelled.

Robin.
Swannanoa, 1989 Shetland Family Four
http://shetlandf4.wordpress.com
User avatar
bobtooke
Posts: 110
Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:26 pm
Location: South London / Newhaven

Re: fuel consuption

Post by bobtooke »

rbmatthews wrote:Dave

Are you really comparing like-for-like here? Mariner 70hp engines were produced up to around 1989, I think - if so, you are really comparing an old 2-stroke engine with a modern 4-stroke. Of course we all know that old 2-strokes were gas-guzzlers, so it is hardly a fair comparison.
Robin, in fairness, I think thats just the point Dave was making. We know that 4-strokes are more efficient than 2-strokes but I for one, was not aware just how drastic that difference can be!

The comment has certainly gone one step further to convincing me to convert to a modern 4-stroke.
Does anyone want to buy a 1988 Mariner 60 from me? :roll:
"Don't worry, I'm completely lost too"
Currently aboard "Sweet Kismet", Shetland 535 / Honda 50

Experts in freshwater treatment to the marine industry.
http://www.amphibia.co.uk
User avatar
stanfolds
Posts: 75
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 12:40 pm
Location: Livvi, Shetland 570, Horning Norfolk.

Re: fuel consuption

Post by stanfolds »

Robin,

Getting a reasonably long run on the broads at 6MPH can be difficult, sailing boats tacking across narrow rivers can bring you to a halt at times. I considered weighing the tank but felt there was too big an area for errors. GPS for logging the distance doesn't take the current/tide into account and there are no tidal stream atlases available, even the times of high and low water are at best estimates. If I remember correctly, my last guestimate of consumption was 8 Miles/litre so 250 mils should give about a 2 mile run so Thurne Mouth to Acle should be OK.

Stan
rbmatthews
Posts: 106
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:02 am
Location: Northeast Scotland

Re: fuel consumption

Post by rbmatthews »

bobtooke wrote: Robin, in fairness, I think thats just the point Dave was making. We know that 4-strokes are more efficient than 2-strokes but I for one, was not aware just how drastic that difference can be!

The comment has certainly gone one step further to convincing me to convert to a modern 4-stroke.
Bob: I suppose my point was that if you are considering upgrading from an old 2-stroke to a modern engine then a modern 2-stroke is as good as the same power modern 4-stroke as far as the fuel consumption is concerned. But there will be other factors to consider as well - weight, cost, availability, maintenance costs, reliability, etc. It just depends on the relative importance you give to each of these. Everyone to his own.
stanfolds wrote: Getting a reasonably long run on the broads at 6MPH can be difficult, sailing boats tacking across narrow rivers can bring you to a halt at times. I considered weighing the tank but felt there was too big an area for errors. GPS for logging the distance doesn't take the current/tide into account and there are no tidal stream atlases available, even the times of high and low water are at best estimates. If I remember correctly, my last guestimate of consumption was 8 Miles/litre so 250 mils should give about a 2 mile run so Thurne Mouth to Acle should be OK.
Stan: Fair enough. It will be interesting to see the figures you come up with. 8 miles/litre is something we only dream of!

R.
Swannanoa, 1989 Shetland Family Four
http://shetlandf4.wordpress.com
User avatar
bobtooke
Posts: 110
Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:26 pm
Location: South London / Newhaven

Re: fuel consuption

Post by bobtooke »

Dave, what exact make/model was on the 535? Achieving 30mph at that level of consumption is very good & I may be in the running for buying one soon.
"Don't worry, I'm completely lost too"
Currently aboard "Sweet Kismet", Shetland 535 / Honda 50

Experts in freshwater treatment to the marine industry.
http://www.amphibia.co.uk
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: fuel consuption

Post by daveinglasgow »

Hi

To be fair I think you would get these figures with suzi engines as well but as you know I get the choice of suze, mariner /mercury optimax, tohatsu and honda and I must admit that though the suzi came a close 2nd I put a nice silver Honda on the back :D

oh and yes I can deliver !


Dave
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
daveg
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon May 20, 2013 10:32 am

Re: fuel consuption

Post by daveg »

Interesting topic. We have just got our 535 on the water and have done a couple of short trips. Engine is an old Yamaha 28hp 2 stroke professionally serviced and apparently in good condition despite its age.

Fuel consumption is more than 1 litre per mile. Top speed is 6mph.

45 miles using 12.5l and a top speed of over 30mph sounds more like what I am after. Is this really the typical performance of a new 4 stroke engine?

Even a UK price of about £6,000 for a new 50hp Honda the fuel savings alone would justify the outlay.
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: fuel consuption

Post by daveinglasgow »

Hi

depends on the engine i.e honda ecomode and suzi lean burn yes. think of this tech as driving down the motorway in 5th gear at 56mph. i.e. both manufactures have worked out that cruising speed for most people on these engines is between 4-4.8k revs and hence this a pottering around ie sub 2k revs is what they are optimized for.

I just wish there was no vat on these things as this would make it easier for more people to buy.
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices