2stroke v 4stroke
-
Marty
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2014 1:27 pm
2stroke v 4stroke
Any ideas on a 2stroke or a 4stroke outboard for my sealark,and what sizes thanks
-
rbmatthews
- Posts: 106
- Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:02 am
- Location: Northeast Scotland
Re: 2stroke v 4stroke
I suspect there will as many different opinions on this topic as there are members, depending on what they currently have!
To kick things off, a little while ago I did a comparison of fuel consumptions of a modern two-stroke and a four-stroke 75 hp based on the data supplied by the manufacturers, and came to the conclusion that there probably wasn't any difference between the two in practice; if anything, the two-stroke was slightly more economical at WOT:
http://shetlandf4.wordpress.com/2013/10 ... -4-stroke/
It would be interesting to see if this relationship held up across the range of engine sizes and for other makes.
Of course, there will be other factors to consider as well - cost, weight, intended use, reliability, etc, - so best to do your background research and make your choice.
Not sure what size to suggest but you should check first of all with the boat specs (on the Shetland Boats site?) what the manufacturer's maximum size is. Didn't you have a 20 or 25 hp in mind?
R.
To kick things off, a little while ago I did a comparison of fuel consumptions of a modern two-stroke and a four-stroke 75 hp based on the data supplied by the manufacturers, and came to the conclusion that there probably wasn't any difference between the two in practice; if anything, the two-stroke was slightly more economical at WOT:
http://shetlandf4.wordpress.com/2013/10 ... -4-stroke/
It would be interesting to see if this relationship held up across the range of engine sizes and for other makes.
Of course, there will be other factors to consider as well - cost, weight, intended use, reliability, etc, - so best to do your background research and make your choice.
Not sure what size to suggest but you should check first of all with the boat specs (on the Shetland Boats site?) what the manufacturer's maximum size is. Didn't you have a 20 or 25 hp in mind?
R.
Swannanoa, 1989 Shetland Family Four
http://shetlandf4.wordpress.com
http://shetlandf4.wordpress.com
-
Marty
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2014 1:27 pm
Re: 2stroke v 4stroke
Been getting lots of advice on outboards, this is all new to me I have only ever had a portabote with a 2.5 hp for close to shore fishing,I got a very good deal on the sealark and I'm just being careful on an engine choice.a new engine with its warranty will be a good investment and if looked after should last me a long time even longer than the sealark. It's looking like a 25 or 30 at a push very expensive but worth it when I am out with my kids piece of mind. Thanks for all the advice
-
bobtooke
- Posts: 110
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:26 pm
- Location: South London / Newhaven
Re: 2stroke v 4stroke
If you want to get the hull to plane I'm not convinced a 30hp is quite enough. Maybe a 40hp would be better?
"Don't worry, I'm completely lost too"
Currently aboard "Sweet Kismet", Shetland 535 / Honda 50
Experts in freshwater treatment to the marine industry.
http://www.amphibia.co.uk
Currently aboard "Sweet Kismet", Shetland 535 / Honda 50
Experts in freshwater treatment to the marine industry.
http://www.amphibia.co.uk
-
Guest
Re: 2stroke v 4stroke
Hi Marty,
Not sure if a 30 hp would plane that boat,but a 40hp sounds like it should. On the question of 2 versus 4 strokes iv,e had a Mercury 60 2 stroke and am currently running a Honda 75hp 4 stroke on our 4+2 for out and out economy and total reliability and ease of operation i would say nothing beats a 4 stroke,in my case the Honda is a gem of a motor. As for the size,just remember this old saying '''There's no replacement for displacement''' !!
Not sure if a 30 hp would plane that boat,but a 40hp sounds like it should. On the question of 2 versus 4 strokes iv,e had a Mercury 60 2 stroke and am currently running a Honda 75hp 4 stroke on our 4+2 for out and out economy and total reliability and ease of operation i would say nothing beats a 4 stroke,in my case the Honda is a gem of a motor. As for the size,just remember this old saying '''There's no replacement for displacement''' !!