Stainless prop re aluminium
-
ladydawn
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2013 4:26 pm
- Location: 4+2 soft top with 75 hp Honda on twin axle extreme trailer .
Stainless prop re aluminium
This one,s for admin, the Solas stainless prop on my boat has a rubber hub which is a seperate item but came with the prop from new, this hub should slip in the event of the prop hitting an underwater immovable object, thus saving the gearbox from any further damage due to the prop itself being unyielding. Hav,nt as yet tested this theory due to the broads being fairly crap free. We cruised just about all of the broads in 1 week and when i removed the prop last week to re install the aluminium prop that we use for the river ouse in Bedford (just attended the Bedford river festival this last weekend) the stainless prop was as new with no dings whatever, so have now polished the prop and put it back in its box ready for next time.
The prop was bought new from steel developments in London.The chap there has a wealth of knowledge on the subject of props and i suggest if he cant get a 4+2 planing with a 75 Honda then nobody can !!!
-
daveinglasgow
- Posts: 680
- Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
- Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond
Re: Stainless prop re aluminium
lol I love the stainless steal comments. the biggest factors are power, weight , weight distribution , fins, conditions and then stainless over ali prob but as this is such a tiny difference I would have the others sorted out first and then and only then would I make such a comment!
Dave
Dave
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
-
ladydawn
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2013 4:26 pm
- Location: 4+2 soft top with 75 hp Honda on twin axle extreme trailer .
Re: Stainless prop re aluminium
Hi Dave, Just a quick note regarding your last comments on stainless steel versus aluminium props, i,m afraid you,ve taken my comments out of context thats why you found them amusing. I,ve been in contact with admin via the gift of mobile phone texting and whilst you say weight distribution is important its by no means the end of the story,for example admins 4+2 is a hard top thus theyve got approx 150 kgs more weight at the rear. the second point is admin has only got a 40 ltr water tank in the bow,whereas ive got 110 ltr so thats an extrs 70 kgs up front also admins engine and ours are the same ( Honda 75 hp fourstroke). The point i was making about props and stainless props in particular is a question of rigidity ie stainless is far less likely to flex,particularly during the acceleration stage.... ( Hole shot for the yanks amongst us ) . also admins pitch was too coarse to allow the engine to accelerate to anywhere near max bhp, so it wasnt revving enough.Also i mentioned trim tabs to admin because a set of fins on the outboard would not produce as much lift as tabs,as the lifting area of the fins is not as great as the tabs. Also max speed depends on the surface roughness of the bottom of the boat. Ive been experimenting for the past forty years with all these things because ive been building RC offshore powerboats competitively with quite a few wins under my belt !
-
daveinglasgow
- Posts: 680
- Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
- Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond
Re: Stainless prop re aluminium
Hi
I think I must be missreading again sorry as
1: the difference is performence between an ali prop and a stainless is minimal and one of the least factors in any boat getting up out of the water
2: as per my last post weight is the biggest factor then followed by weight distribution, then fins ( not trim tabs as these having nothing to do with getting a boat on the plane but help with corrosion and steering), then conditions. Oh and surface roughness again is not an issue unless the boat has picked up some rubbish by not being anti-fouled.
re also admins pitch was too coarse to allow the engine to accelerate to anywhere near max bhp, so it wasnt revving enough
FYI the revs on admins ( Sue to me) were miles out and not just a change in 1 or 2 prop sizes and she has now had it looked at and sorted the engine management out and is now getting full revs at Wide open throttle.
so before anyone messes around with a stainless prop and risks hundreds of pounds replacing a gearbox.
1: see if you can reduce the weight i.e. carry what you need and not all the extra's that will never get used as we see so often ( I am taking it for granted that the engine has the right prop and has had a compression test)
2: get the weight in the right place. this is a problem for most small cabin cruisers and many are far to heavy in the back ( The stern) and light in the front ( bow) so move spare fuel around , batteries anchors etc.
3: add fins as this will help get the boat up at a lower speed
If the above fails either change your engine ( or the boat!) or accept that you will not be getting the boat on the plane. if you do insist having a stainless prop then yes you will get an extra mile an hour but if you hit anything....... well enjoy spending 600-2000 for a gearbox (based on 40hp engines upwards) and in my opinion not a risk worth taking for most people.
Dave
I think I must be missreading again sorry as
1: the difference is performence between an ali prop and a stainless is minimal and one of the least factors in any boat getting up out of the water
2: as per my last post weight is the biggest factor then followed by weight distribution, then fins ( not trim tabs as these having nothing to do with getting a boat on the plane but help with corrosion and steering), then conditions. Oh and surface roughness again is not an issue unless the boat has picked up some rubbish by not being anti-fouled.
re also admins pitch was too coarse to allow the engine to accelerate to anywhere near max bhp, so it wasnt revving enough
FYI the revs on admins ( Sue to me) were miles out and not just a change in 1 or 2 prop sizes and she has now had it looked at and sorted the engine management out and is now getting full revs at Wide open throttle.
so before anyone messes around with a stainless prop and risks hundreds of pounds replacing a gearbox.
1: see if you can reduce the weight i.e. carry what you need and not all the extra's that will never get used as we see so often ( I am taking it for granted that the engine has the right prop and has had a compression test)
2: get the weight in the right place. this is a problem for most small cabin cruisers and many are far to heavy in the back ( The stern) and light in the front ( bow) so move spare fuel around , batteries anchors etc.
3: add fins as this will help get the boat up at a lower speed
If the above fails either change your engine ( or the boat!) or accept that you will not be getting the boat on the plane. if you do insist having a stainless prop then yes you will get an extra mile an hour but if you hit anything....... well enjoy spending 600-2000 for a gearbox (based on 40hp engines upwards) and in my opinion not a risk worth taking for most people.
Dave
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
-
admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 862
- Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2011 3:00 pm
- Location: "Phonix" , Tuckton Basin, Christchurch
Re: Stainless prop re aluminium
Gentlemen, I have to thank both of you for your invaluable advice.
Tim, if I hadn't read your post I would have not thought anything was wrong other than the boat was heavier than we thought. So thank you for your post especially as we have very similar set ups
Dave, as usual, spot on mate. Thank you.
Update, prop changed to 13 inch Ali, some result but the problem lies with the engine itself. Bow has been weighed down with enough ballast to pebble a drive way. Throttle is opening normally, no blocked air intake filter so........ Boils down to engine computer problem. Honda engineers are on the case first thing Tuesday morning as still under warranty.
We will then get back into the Solent for a sea test, which should be interesting as this week is Cowes week and it's knee deep in fecking SHOUTY, racing raggies types who just don't give way to anything and think more than normal that they own the sea. (Rant over)
I will keep you posted.....
Sue
Tim, if I hadn't read your post I would have not thought anything was wrong other than the boat was heavier than we thought. So thank you for your post especially as we have very similar set ups
Dave, as usual, spot on mate. Thank you.
Update, prop changed to 13 inch Ali, some result but the problem lies with the engine itself. Bow has been weighed down with enough ballast to pebble a drive way. Throttle is opening normally, no blocked air intake filter so........ Boils down to engine computer problem. Honda engineers are on the case first thing Tuesday morning as still under warranty.
We will then get back into the Solent for a sea test, which should be interesting as this week is Cowes week and it's knee deep in fecking SHOUTY, racing raggies types who just don't give way to anything and think more than normal that they own the sea. (Rant over)
I will keep you posted.....
Sue
There is NOTHING--absolutely nothing--half so much worth doing as simply messing about in boats.
Kenneth Grahame
Kenneth Grahame