Which Shetland for coastal?

Thoughts, Ideas and General Questions
Prologica
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2023 2:34 pm

Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by Prologica »

Hi,
I'm completely new to motorboats being a sailor primarily. Moving shortly to Essex coast with opportunity to lay a mooring in a drying creek, soft mud, some shingle so outboard will need to be raised easily. Looking to buy a used motor boat to get around the creeks, rivers and coast. Will be my wife and I most times, plus family including grandkids, friends and others. The occasional night aboard would be nice. Saw a Shetland Personnel Carrier advertised, no model number, which looked a good option but only 9hp outboard. Carries up to 10 passengers.
Would welcome your experienced insight re which used models might be suitable, what not to buy, what to watch out for, eBay or not, etc.

Many thanks
P
blebrocq
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2022 11:24 am

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by blebrocq »

You would need a fair bit more than 9 HP for coastal work, & you would also be advised to have provision for a 2nd engine, usualy mounted on a raisable bracket. You should have flares & a VHF radio on board (or at least a mobile phone !)
I would say for your purposes a 19 ft boat would be minimum length (570, Kestrel, Black Hawk, Saker etc.) fitted with at least a 40 HP motor.
If you realy want take 10 people then you would need more like a 30 ft boat (Shetland 27, or Shetland offshore.
Bob
Clive
Posts: 548
Joined: Sun Jun 23, 2019 8:41 am

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by Clive »

Agree with Bob. You really need to pin down what will be its primary use. We have a 4+2 which is 21ft (so does Bob) and very comfortable for its size but can’t carry 10 and is more of a fair weather cruiser. Most boats have a load capacity. How often will you want to overnight? Or carry lots of family? I did a YHA powerboat level 2 course which is invaluable for even experienced boaters and topped it up with a course to get me a VHF licence which is a legal requirement by Ofcom for coastal work. Try to avoid getting over excited and if it seems cheap (or less than you thought) be wary, there are many boats out there and lots that have been neglected! Wait for the good one. All boats need lots of maintenance as you will know so be prepared for a new hobby or deep pockets. Good luck and post some pics. Lots of 535s around which are great for coastal work. Watch out for leaks in windows hatches etc and soggy floors from wet foam, that’s a really big job!
4+2 (1988) 35hp Honda outboard, currently in a field outside Horsham.
Prologica
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2023 2:34 pm

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by Prologica »

Thanks Bob and Clive, good points well made. I agree 9hp outboard is far too underpowered.
I'm Day Skipper and ICC qualified with a VHF qualification so that includes power and I've used tenders with outboards before but nothing too powerful.
So re usage: it would be fair weather only F4 max I would say but ideally no more than F3. I think realistically it will be my wife and I only. We probably wouldn't overnight often and would be prepared to rough it a bit in that department, sleeping bags, single bunk cushions. I think we would quite often have two adult guests aboard and two children (teens in future years) but I don't expect guests to sleep aboard. I expect our farthest outbound passage would be 15nm (30 return) but mostly it would be 3-7 nm outbound.
The 10 seater peaked my interest for the very occasional times when the whole family gets together, which would be 8 adults plus.
I wouldn't want anything too large.
Cheers
David
dconnx
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu May 18, 2023 8:27 am

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by dconnx »

We have an old Shetland family four moored in a sea marina (Greystones, Co. Wicklow, Ireland). Really max four people aboard because of the limited outdoor space (but it's usually 2 of us so not really an issue). We have a new 50HP Suzuki outboard on it (DF50A) and it's doing a great job. As someone else here on the board detailed, and was right, it will get the family four on a plane right up around 6,000 RPM but will then keep the plane when dropping down to 5,000 RPM and this lets us move at up to 20 to 25 knots at sea which is great and I'm pretty happy with our fuel usage (yesterday we went about 33KM/20miles - Greystones->Howth at about 13 litres of petrol - I know shocking compared to a car) - until it planes the bow is right up in the air and moving really slowly (and I suspect this in-between state is probably very fuel consuming) so I think less than 50HP might be a problem to get the boat to plane. I had to choose between the 40/50/60 HP engine when buying it earlier this year (they are the same actual engine which is a bit weird but just computer limited, and actually priced, by output HP). I do believe a backup engine is vital but now that we have a new engine we've been a bit lax in testing the backup (my son did the other day and it took him more than 10s of pulls of the starter to get the old 6HP 2 stroke Evinrude running - at least it did start - but I think this might suggest that I should be thinking about getting a better backup engine. I don't want to be one of those people that I hear, on the radio, the RNLI going out to rescue and just yesterday it was really great weather but there was quite an amount of rescues taking place).
dellquay13
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by dellquay13 »

The best Shetland hulls for coastal (in my biased opinion) are the gullwinged Family Four or 536 and the slightly larger 570 (and later variants built on the same hull like the black hawk, saker)
They are perfect for a couple to sleep aboard with a pram hood. They will cope with up to 4 adults aboard if you aren’t bouncing around at 20knots. With full loading the F4 works best with at least 60hp, I find 70hp just right. The 570 variants need 70-90hp.
The 535 hull is much lighter and a traditional medium Vee, they slam slightly less in big seas but are not as stable at rest. They are all at least 50years old now, and more Spartan than the later gullwing models. Being lighter the engine can be smaller at 50-60hp.
The bigger models like 4+2 are shallow Vee, and will be happy coastal pottering in sheltered conditions, but would really need big outboards in reserve and all the crockery and table lamps in bubblewrap if the seas pick up. They are more about the increased cabin space not cockpit, so even though they are bigger hulls, they don’t really carry more adults at sea.
While I love my F4, I can see why so many people buy the European pilothouse fast fishers like Beneteau or Quicksilver
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
blebrocq
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2022 11:24 am

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by blebrocq »

In my opinion of the "570" options the Black Hawk (or later "Hawk") variant is the most suited for occasional sleeping on. With a separate toilet compartment, & a galley area (sink & draining board) in the cabin, they can be made to be quite cosy.
Bob
dellquay13
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by dellquay13 »

dconnx wrote: Mon Sep 04, 2023 9:32 pm until it planes the bow is right up in the air and moving really slowly (and I suspect this in-between state is probably very fuel consuming)
It is very fuel hungry like that. Are you trimming the engine fully in before trying to get on the plane, trimming back out once up? Getting weight distribution equal fore and aft at rest is helpful too.
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
dellquay13
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 7:45 am
Location: Pequod, F4 mk4, Milford Haven Marina

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by dellquay13 »

blebrocq wrote: Tue Sep 05, 2023 7:31 am In my opinion of the "570" options the Black Hawk (or later "Hawk") variant is the most suited for occasional sleeping on. With a separate toilet compartment, & a galley area (sink & draining board) in the cabin, they can be made to be quite cosy.
Bob
I agree with you about the toilet compartment, but don’t underestimate the galley on the F4. I have spent many 2 week holidays aboard, including trailering to Brittany a few times.
We don’t know the OPs budget or expectations, many of the 570 options like the Hawk, Kestrel Saker are 40 years old and stink of fish guts. The latter F4s with the platform for the outboard have the same amount of space onboard, but with tidier interiors.
I have now sold my 1989 F4 mk4, 2015 70hp 4str Yamaha. Milford Haven. I proudly owned it for over 20 years, before changing to sailpower and a yacht...
captainbadger007
Posts: 6
Joined: Sun Apr 06, 2025 7:15 pm

Re: Which Shetland for coastal?

Post by captainbadger007 »

hi all im looking for some knowledge from you , i have a shetland 536 and there is wter in the cabin while on the trailer, ive undone the drain plug and that got rid of most of it , however there seams to be water under the floor in the cabin , dose anyone know if this should drain, ive taken a part of the floor out and its full of foam ,,also the channel in the middle is also full of foam , what can i do about this as i have no plans to know how to go about this issue , i do have some photos of it but dont know how to add to the post