Advice on engine size please

Thoughts, Ideas and General Questions
Theladsharp
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Jul 23, 2012 5:41 pm

Advice on engine size please

Post by Theladsharp »

Firstly I must tell you that I am a complete novice who has just bought a Shetland 610 of a mate who has emmigrated.

The boat is equipped with a 30 hp outboard engine that was refurbished in Jan 2011, has hardly been used since and has now stopped working.

The local boatyard are saying that the engine is not really appropriate for use on the River Soar and Trent ( where the boat is located) because it is designed for faster speeds than the maximum allowed on these rivers and that it will use about 1 gallon per hour when in use.

They are suggesting that i get the engine refurbished and then try to trade it in against a smaller one.

Would fellow-members consider this good advise. If so, is there anybody out there who might be looking for a swap?
aggalletley
Posts: 63
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2012 4:44 pm

Re: Advice on engine size please

Post by aggalletley »

Might it be better to look at how much a new engine costs with no trade in or a good second hand one with a guarantee. Either write off the old engine or just sell it as it is. Having it refurbished and then traded in to a dealer means the dealer wins four times round. 1/ He makes money on the refurbishment 2/ He gets the recond engine cheap as a trade in. 3/ He makes money on the engine he then sells to you 4/ He then makes a profit on selling the reconed engine
Hope this makes sense. Hope this helps you with the decision
Andrew
deeandmartin
Posts: 99
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2011 12:42 pm
Location: No boat at present based in Mid Wales

Re: Advice on engine size please

Post by deeandmartin »

Our first boat was a 535 which we had fitted with a 50 hp 4 stroke secondhand mariner, we now have a 570 and have just had her fitted this year with a new 100hp 4 stroke mariner. We trailer our boat and took advice on engines as we use her on the sea, the Lakes and rivers, we have found that the 4 stroke engines are particularly good at ticking along at the lower speeds when required but of course also great for any higher speeds, and allows for versatility of use. So far we have also been very impressed with the economy, and quietness of our new engine great at sea and inland. Hope this is of help, Good luck and hope you enjoy your new boat, Dee
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: Advice on engine size please

Post by daveinglasgow »

Hi

Ok, first thing first. You can never have too much power. as long as the boat is rated for the engine then happy days. This is just like a car so who ever told you this is talking rubbish at best.

Next, is the engine 2 or 4 stroke? as this will make a difference and for being on a river a 4 stroke would be miles better

re refurbished. v confused here. why would anyone refurb and then trade in? there are plenty of people needing your engine if its a 2 stroke and if its a 4 stroke i would not even change it so please think about this before you do anything.

Dave
ps feel free to message me with a contact number if you want to chat about this.
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
Theladsharp
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Jul 23, 2012 5:41 pm

Re: Advice on engine size please

Post by Theladsharp »

Hi Dave

Many thanks for your message and advise.

I must admit i am really in a muddle about how best to proceed.

The engine was refurbished in Jan 2011. I bought the boat two months ago from a friend who has emmigrated to the States. The boat was moored 20 miles north of Leicester and part of the deal was that the boat would be delivered by one of my mate's acquaintances to the marina in Leicester where I have paid for a year's mooring. After waiting 3 weeks for the river level to drop to a navigable level, the delivery was attempted. However, I got a call from them saying the boat was running really rough due to overheating and that it had been moored at a halfway point. I contacted the boatyard that performed the refurb who kindly organised for someone to go and tow the boat in to them. They are telling me that it needs a lot of work on it and the reasons for the problems are -

1) the motor had been unused for too long and this is as damaging as over-using them
2) the engine is too powerful for use on the River Soar as it would have to be running at really low revs all the time to conform with the speed limit and that it would burn petrol at the rate of 1 gallon per hour.
3) that I would be better off replacing the motor with a smaller version (they recommend 15hp) but dont recommend a reconditioned unit as they are unreliable.

Unfortunately i can afford the 2 grand or so for a new engine so I'm contemplating truncating my boating career after precisely 6 weeks, selling the boat minus engine and writing-off about £1500 in the process.

Am I getting good advise or do you think the boatyard are trying to cover up for the fact that they didnt refurb the engine properly and are preying of my boating naiveity?

Any help would be gratefully accepted.

Cheers
John
daveinglasgow
Posts: 680
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 9:04 am
Location: Dave Ashton, Shetland 610 Glasgow & Loch lomond

Re: Advice on engine size please

Post by daveinglasgow »

Hi John

please call me on 0759 563 8185 and we can get this sorted.

Happy to help and all we ask it that you dont turn your back on other newbies to the boating world to save them getting ripped off.

Dave
http://www.ashtonmarineservices.co.uk, Brokergae, Trailers, advice, boat transportation 0759 563 8185
https://www.facebook.com/ashtonmarineservices
Neil
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Jun 14, 2012 12:08 pm

Re: Advice on engine size please

Post by Neil »

Hi
Never rely on a second hand engine. The former owner may have neglcted it, and they are not reliable when not in top condition.
I would advise you to invest in a new or nearly new (reconditioned) one. Four stroke are the best, and like the others who have replied to you, I would say go for a more powerful one.
If you are just river or estuary cruising 40/60 hp should be plenty, but if you are thinking of going coastal, I would go up to 80/100hp.